An awkward echo
- Exclusive ContentScan the cover in the app
- CommunityDiscuss & Share
About this book
Matthew Arnold, a nineteenth-century English poet, critic and school inspector, believed every era must work out the philosophy best suited to its own problems and circumstances. This book traces how Arnold shaped the thinking of John Dewey and tries to build a philosophy of education suited to the uneasy present.
Both thinkers are now claimed by rival political camps. Conservative educators often cite Arnold as a defender of a curriculum centred on the great books and Victorian values. Dewey, who keeps a distinctly liberal reputation, is frequently blamed for the failings of progressive education, including failings he had no part in. The author argues that each is misread by people who borrow them as icons for their own educational agendas.
The study argues for a pluralistic education, where pluralism covers many processes as well as many voices. Drawing on rhetoric and hermeneutics, it identifies four aspects of mind that bring Arnold and Dewey into close agreement: the tentacle mind, which follows Dewey's favourite image for dissolving the split between mind and body; the critical mind, which draws on the notion of criticism that guided both men's view of experience; the intentional mind, which revives the idea of authority and questions the limits of reader-response theory; and the reflective-response mind, which gives contemplation an active role rather than letting it isolate the thinker.
The book also considers how Dewey inherited and reworked the ideas of Arnold, who in turn drew on many earlier and contemporary writers. Such borrowing rarely comes out clean, and the author accepts that these inherited ideas are imperfect. The aim is an approach that is imperfect but adequate to present needs.
Reader reviews
No reviews yet. Share your thoughts on this book in the Appilog app.
Book Details
- ISBN
- 9781607523987
- Author
- Mark David Dietz
- Publisher
- Unknown Publisher
- Genres
- PhilosophyEducation & Teaching
Media & Extras
This book has 0 videos that play on its cover. Scan the cover with the Appilog app to watch.
Get the app
