Autonomy and intervention
- Exclusive ContentScan the cover in the app
- CommunityDiscuss & Share
About this book
Kultgen starts from the view that people owe one another care, and that a well-lived life is one devoted to caring for others. Careless care, however, can slide into an unwarranted violation of a person's self-determination. He treats autonomy as a serious good that should be overridden only for strong reasons, yet he insists it is not the only good that matters. In his account, there are times when stepping into someone else's affairs is justified, either to shield them from harm or to secure something valuable for them.
From this starting point, Kultgen argues that caring intervention needs clear rules so that it stays both respectful and even-handed. He takes issue with contemporary thinkers who reject paternalism, meaning interference with someone without their consent, in every form. After showing where their reasoning falls short, he offers a revised framework he calls parentalism.
The new name is deliberate. Kultgen drops the patriarchal associations of paternalism and draws instead on the most effective caring roles traditionally linked with mothers and fathers. He separates the personal domain of friends, family and intimate partners from the public domain of institutions, law and professional practice, and examines how parentalism applies in each.
Kultgen accepts that paternalistic intervention carries real moral danger, but he argues that failing to intervene when another person's welfare is at risk is equally dangerous.
Reader reviews
No reviews yet. Share your thoughts on this book in the Appilog app.
Book Details
- ISBN
- 9780195085310
- Author
- John Kultgen
- Publisher
- Unknown Publisher
- Genres
- Philosophy
Media & Extras
This book has 0 videos that play on its cover. Scan the cover with the Appilog app to watch.
Get the app
