Rogues' Gallery
- Exclusive ContentScan the cover in the app
- CommunityDiscuss & Share
About this book
John Oller follows the birth of professional big-city policing and the rise of the Mafia in New York, tracing crime and punishment through the city's streets in the Gilded Age. He presents it as two intertwined upheavals, each feeding the other. For centuries the city had been a refuge for lawbreakers, and a thief or killer not caught in the act almost always escaped.
In the early 1870s, an Irish cop named Thomas Byrnes changed that. He introduced mug shots and daily lineups so witnesses could pick out suspects, a rogues' gallery that let police track repeat offenders, and the third-degree method that pressured stubborn prisoners into confessing. Byrnes worked cases methodically, questioning witnesses, examining crime scenes, and building theories that solved crimes once considered hopeless. Yet as policing grew more specialized and efficient, criminals adapted. Robberies became bolder and more intricate, killings more merciless and grisly, and the old street gangs evolved into tiered criminal enterprises, the origins of organized crime, including the Mafia. Over the following decades, corrupt officers and savvy criminals sometimes became hard to tell apart, until waves of police reform led by figures such as Theodore Roosevelt pushed back.
The book is populated by vivid figures. Marm Mandelbaum, a motherly German immigrant, bribed police and politicians to shield her fencing operation for stolen goods. Clubber Williams, a sadistic officer, swung a twenty-six-inch club at suspects whether or not they were guilty. Danny Driscoll led the Irish Whyos gang with violence and was possibly the city's first crime boss. Big Tim Sullivan, a crooked Tammany Hall politician, protected the Whyos from the law. Paul Kelly, a smooth Italian, and Monk Eastman, a brutal Jewish gang leader, led rival crews whose brawls and shootouts swept the Lower East Side. Joe Petrosino, a Sicilian-born detective, pursued early Mafiosi and Black Hand extortionists until a fateful return trip to Italy.
The story unfolds against Gilded Age New York, a city of extreme plutocratic wealth, tenement poverty, and mounting social unrest. It will appeal to readers interested in the origins of modern policing and organized crime, and it draws connections between that era and the present day.
Reader reviews
No reviews yet. Share your thoughts on this book in the Appilog app.
Book Details
- ISBN
- 9781524745653
- Author
- John Oller
- Publisher
- Unknown Publisher
- Genres
- HistoryTrue Crime
Media & Extras
This book has 0 videos that play on its cover. Scan the cover with the Appilog app to watch.
Get the app




