Wrong Bed Baby

Caleb, the new neighbor next door, is an elementary school teacher who flirts with nearly everyone he meets. The narrator flirts back in a relaxed way, and their banter stays light until the night he accidentally ends up in her bed. She is inclined to see the whole thing as fate, so she doesn't waste the opportunity. Caleb is confident and charming, and he lives up to his reputation.

Soon her cravings take a surprising turn toward pickle-flavored ice cream with peanut butter sauce and a cherry on top. The complication is that Caleb has never wanted a family or a lasting commitment, or at least he believed he didn't. As he becomes a soon-to-be father, he discovers that the woman he has been teasing will return his advances three times over.

This standalone accidental pregnancy romantic comedy has a happily ever after ending and no cliffhanger.